1Using a common difference of the terms
The terms of a harmonic sequence are treated as an arithmetic sequence: a common difference is read off from the first two terms, and the formula an=a1+(n−1)d is applied to the terms themselves instead of to their reciprocals. StartFor 31,51,71,…, Wrong turnError hered=51−31=−152,
a10=31+9⋅(−152)=−1513
Right pathThe arithmetic sequence is the denominators 3,5,7,…, with b1=3 and d=2. b10=3+9⋅2=21,a10=b101=211 Why it happensThe general-term formula of an arithmetic sequence is the one most practised, and the difference is taken of whatever numbers are written down, not of their reciprocals.
How to checkCompute a second difference. 71−51=−352, which is not −152, so the terms are not arithmetic. A negative answer is also impossible here: every term of this sequence is a positive fraction. 2Concluding convergence from shrinking terms
Because the terms n1 approach zero, the harmonic series is taken to add up to some finite total. Wrong turnError heren1→0, so the later additions become negligible and the partial sums settle at a limit.
Right pathGroup the terms as in the grouping proof. The block from 2k+11 to 2k+11 has 2k terms, each at least 2k+11, so it adds at least 21:
H2k≥1+2k The partial sums pass every bound, so the series diverges.
Why it happensFor the geometric series, terms that shrink to zero go together with a finite sum, and the condition that the terms approach zero gets mistaken for a test that settles convergence.
How to checkPut in a size. With k=20 the bound gives H220≥11, so the first 1,048,576 terms already add up to more than 10, and the next blocks keep adding at least 21 each. 3Averaging the terms instead of their reciprocals
The term between two neighbours in a harmonic sequence, or a harmonic mean between two values, is found by averaging the two values directly, as in an arithmetic sequence.
StartBetween 31 and 71, Wrong turnError here21(31+71)=21⋅2110=215
Right pathAverage the reciprocals 3 and 7, then take the reciprocal back. 23+7=5,so the term is 51 The two-number formula gives the same: H=31+712⋅31⋅71=2110212=51. Why it happensThe rule "a term is the average of its neighbours" is true for arithmetic sequences and is carried over without the step down to the reciprocals.
How to checkTake reciprocals of the three terms; they must form an arithmetic sequence. 3,5,7 does, with difference 2. The wrong answer gives 3,521,7, with differences 56 and 514. 4Averaging speeds with the arithmetic mean
Two speeds held over equal distances are averaged with the arithmetic mean, as if the trip spent equal time at each speed.
Start60 km/h out and 40 km/h back over the same road, Wrong turnError here260+40=50
Right pathTake the distance as 120 km each way. The trip out takes 60120=2 hours and the trip back 40120=3 hours, so 240 km take 5 hours:
5240=48=60+402⋅60⋅40 The average speed is the harmonic mean, 48 km/h, whatever the distance. Why it happensThe arithmetic mean is the everyday meaning of "average", and it is right when equal times are spent at each speed. With equal distances, more time is spent at the slower speed, which pulls the average down.
How to checkWork out the total time from the claimed average. At 50 km/h, 240 km would take 4.8 hours, but the two legs actually take 5 hours.